Saturday, July 14, 2012

Woody Guthrie at 100.

I knew I loved Woody Guthrie before I even heard him.

That was because of the idea of Woody Guthrie — an irresistibly simple tale, brought forth to the public imagination by the young Bob Dylan — Woody Guthrie was this guy who rambled around America during the Great Depression Dust Bowl & wrote beautiful, piercing songs that captured what life was like.  Dylan once famously said that if you listened to his records, you could learn how to live.  Yeah, it was kind of like that.

The truth, of course, is more complicated & uglier in a way — when I finally did hear Woody Guthrie, he didn't have the nestled-in gravel of Dylan, but rather a sharp, nasal sound that rolled over his dust-dry melodies & hammer-on-filled guitar picking.  It didn't sound sweeping or epic, but more like a wiry little guy who someone asked to stand in a room & run through some songs.  But maybe that was the point all along.

When I finally got myself an education in Guthrie-ism by reading Joe Klein's remarkable Woody Guthrie: A Life from 1981, it turns out that the backstory is closer to the stark sound of what I first heard, as opposed to the dream I had first thought.  Klein makes no bones about it — he says in his introduction that, until he wrote this book, he had the image of Woody Guthrie as a hobo with a guitar, heading off to see what was around the next corner & singing "This Land Is Your Land."  He made Guthrie sound like Johnny Appleseed, a myth to tell the kiddies.  The reality, he wrote, was often at odds to this idea, & a whole lot more complicated.

When Woody Guthrie hit the road in the 1930s, he was married with children.  He would just sort of up & leave them with little-to-no warning, & when he would return home, he would pace the floor restlessly.  The book taught me that he didn't spend the entire time on one big romantic, aimless trip — a hobo's On the Road — but just took a ton of little trips, circling from his native Oklahoma, up around the Dust Bowl & out West, & then back home for a few weeks or days or minutes.  & then he was off again.  It was less like a hungry search than it was an obsessive restlessness.

But the disconnect between how we think of Guthrie & what he actually did was first bridged by none other than Guthrie himself.  Just read his autobiography, Bound for Glory, & you'll instantly understand how quickly the romanticism can overpower the reality.  From the hobos singing "This train is bound for glory" on the first page, it strikes perfect poses between fact & fiction, history & remembrance.

For everything that Guthrie was or wasn't, he had a shrewd understanding of America, & what it meant.  The land was big, & it was ours, & the only thing that could be done was to live in it — go to the Dakotas, travel to California, see the lazy Rio Grande.  The fact that he did so in a time in which the land was at its worst — the Dust Bowl — only makes his plight that much more fascinating — &, perhaps, modern.  Struggling with this wide-eyed wonder is people starving & black dust storms that felt like nothing less than an apocalypse. My favorite Woody Guthrie song is "The Great Dust Storm," in which he covers a single day — April 14, 1935 — & cuts all around the country to document its fallout.  But for all of the wonderful little lines about here & there — "In old Dodge City, Kansas, the wind it blew so strong/They thought that they could hold out but they didn't know how long" — the best lines are focused on a much tighter scene:

& the families they were huddled
Into their oil boom-shacks
& the children then was crying
As it whistled through the cracks.

Who wrote songs where wind storms whistle through the cracks of clapboard poverty shacks?  In 1935, no less?!  It was as though the great American persona — blunt, dry, & deadpan — had found its way to a guy with the observational skills of a Dante & the scope of a Joyce.  In these four lines, you can all but unlock Bob Dylan's first three albums.

Of course, for all of the stuff I've seen about the Guthrie centennial, I've seen no mention of "The Great Dust Storm."  Everyone opts instead for "This Land Is Your Land," which makes sense; even Woody would tell you that the best thing a writer can do is hook their reader in right away.  Everyone knows the song, even if they don't really know it, the wheat fields waving, the diamond deserts.  &, as you've probably already read about half a dozen times, that song was a protest song written in disgust against "God Bless America," & given the most unforgotten "forgotten" verse in American song: A lovely final one in which a private property sign says nothing on its other side — & that side was made for you & me — that guaranteed it would never be included in anything other than Joe McCarthy's playlist.

But for me, "The Great Dust Storm" is the one that brings it all together.  In it, you get Guthrie the poet & Guthrie the reporter, as well as the first evidence that the two don't have to be mutually exclusive.  It was this lesson that Dylan took in the deepest, & in turn, every songwriter in his wake, from Bruce Springsteen down through Josh Ritter.  Is it any wonder Dylan would begin to write songs by reading a newspaper?

Like America, Woody Guthrie is a lot — mythic, romantic, lofty, flawed, rough, untamed, uncivilized, beautiful, epic, compromised, disappointing, heroic, brave, & free.  He's a big ol' mess of contradictions, suspicions, rumors, & lies that we'll probably never come close to getting to the bottom of.  But, for the 3-&-a-half some-odd minutes that I hear "The Great Dust Storm" play, I hear nothing but the stark observation of a man with the rare trick to evoke the senses & humanize the epic.  Compared to "This Land Is Your Land," there are no wistful sweeps to marvel at, no catchy refrain that could be taught to school children.  & yet, somehow there is still that shadow of the romantic.

The romanticism, it seems, is supplied by none other than me, turning me from a listener of to a participant of the song, & in turn, the Guthrie myth, the Guthrie persona, & most important, the Guthrie America.

For all of the bumps & scratches — in his voice, in his songs, in the recordings — it still somehow all pulls together into something more epic & beautiful than the some of its parts.

No wonder he still resonates — & inspires.

Wednesday, July 4, 2012

The Top 10 American Albums.

Well, it's the 4th of July today, so I suppose now is as good of a time as any to try & do something that I've been meaning to do fer years: See if I can boil down the essence of American music into a Top 10 list.  Is it crass & stupid to do so?  Yeah, it probably is.  But has that ever stopped Americans before?  No, it probably hasn't.

& in my definition of "American Album," it needs to be made by an artist or group who is from America.  Thus, The Band's self-titled "Brown Album" does not qualify, nor do the US-obsessed recordings of Bono & Co.  When it got down to the last few, I decided to go with albums that had vocals over ones that didn't & favored musical artists over comedians & show tunes.

Otherwise, I just went fer breadth, scope — & Americanism.


1.  The Complete Hot Fives & Sevens by Louis Armstrong. (1925-1930/2002)

This is where music in America became American music.  The sound achieved by Louis Armstrong's original Hot Five may not have invented jazz, but it perfected the sound.  Specifically, the triple lead parts of Armstrong's trumpet, Kid Ory's trombone, & Johnny Dodds's clarinet kept the sound cooking with an orderly chaos, instruments weaving in & out of each other, in a way that somehow seemed both orderly & improvised.  Throw in Armstrong's charismatic vocals (& groundbreaking scatting) & you have a music that bears the fruit of extensive expertise, but casually knocked off in late-night sessions where almost anything could happen — & did.  If America is truly the cradle of freedom, this is the first music to rock the cradle.


2.  The Sun Sessions by Elvis Presley. (1954-1955/1976)

At less than 3 dozen songs in its original issue (15, plus & one alternate take), this is one of the cornerstones of American music.  Like Armstrong, Elvis didn't invent the music so much as he mastered it & perfected it as an art form for others to follow.  If Elvis is the biggest figure in America's biggest music, it's striking how small these founding documents are.  At the center of the Sun recordings are 10 perfect sides — 5 R&B songs backed by 5 country sides — that combined are less than 25 minutes.  But with tunes like "That's All Right," "Good Rockin' Tonight," "Mystery Train," & the rest, this is about as rich as music gets, as you hear so many influences — blues & country, electric & acoustic, rural & urban, black & white — while also hearing ELVIS.  & what a rush it is.


3.  Lady in Satin by Billie Holiday. (1958)

The most controversial album by America's greatest singer, Lady in Satin has long divided its audiences & critics, & for obvious reasons.  Holiday was far past her prime by the time she made these records & it shows in every gravely twist of every nuanced word.  But Holiday's chief innovation to popular music was to bring the emotion of the song to the forefront, not simply singing the song but performing it, akin to how an actor may read their lines.  Everyone from Frank Sinatra & Elvis on down has been influenced by her one way or another, & this, her final masterwork, plays just like it sounds: A world-weary master standing at the end of a long road.  It is also, not coincidentally, the work that she felt was the finest of her career.


4.  Songs for Swinging Lovers! by Frank Sinatra. (1956)

There are two sides of America, & Sinatra caught them both — & in a row at that.  There is the late-night, failed & lonely, what-coulda-been lament that he captured in his first full-length album, In the Wee Small Hours, & there is the bright-&-shiny exuberance of his follow-up, Songs for Swinging Lovers! From the opening "You Make Me Feel So Young" onward, the music is as joyful as In the Wee Small Hours was stark, with Sinatra's vocals — bold, blunt, offhanded, cocky, & charming — at the height of its power.  It's his voice that drives the album, a seemingly effortless extension of his personality & style.  I mean, no matter who they are, everybody likes at least one Sinatra song.  It would be almost un-American not to.


5.  The Freewheelin' Bob Dylan by Bob Dylan. (1963)

If Bob Dylan did nothing more than release this, his 2nd album (but his 1st to be made up almost entirely original material), his place in the American musical canon would be secured.  The songs play like a greatest hits not just of Dylan's folk period, but of folk, period — as "Blowin' in the Wind," "Masters of War," "Don't Think Twice, It's All Right," & "A Hard Rain's A-Gonna Fall" changed not just the way people listened to or wrote music, but how they thought about it.  A master of a thousand voices, a mimic, a poet, a comedian, & a philosopher all in one, Dylan proves for the first time (& 3 days after his 22nd birthday, at that!) that his greatest voice is his own.


6.  Thriller, Michael Jackson (1982)

It used to be that rock was rock & pop was pop.  Not so after Michael Jackson came along.  Arriving just as rock & roll's central narrative was splintering at the seams, spinning into R&B, funk, rap, heavy metal, & a thousand more subcategories of subcategories, Jackson did something unimaginable: He brought them all together in one place, Thriller, which still stands as the greatest-selling album of all-time.  The songs of Thriller have become so ubiquitous that it's hard to hear how great (& innovative) they truly are — the cool funk of "Billie Jean," the street-smarts of "Beat It," the B-movie extravaganza of the title track.  There is not a dull moment in the pack, & to be sure, it became the template for countless other performers, with varying levels of success.  But Thriller stands above them all.



7.  The Cole Porter Songbook by Ella Fitzgerald. (1956)

In terms of range, training, pitch, & elocution, Ella Fitzgerald was probably the finest singer America has ever produced.  & she seemed to capitalize on her role with this, the 1st in what would become a legendary (some might say definitive) series of Fitzgerald covering America's songwriters.  The Cole Porter album is significant not only because it is 1st, but because Cole Porter holds such a big space in the popular imagination of popular song.  Unlike many of his contemporaries who wrote in music/lyricist pairs, Porter did everything himself — & with results like "Night & Day," "I Get a Kick Out of You," & "I've Got You Under My Skin," who could blame him?  Give them to the First Lady of Song to sing & you have the American song in its Platonic form.



8.  At Folsom Prison, Johnny Cash. (1968)

If America could talk, it might have a voice like Johnny Cash's.  Loud, forceful, & fearless, yet also able to spin a joke & tall-tale or two.  When Cash recorded this, he met his match in the inmates of Folsom Prison, California; indeed, the wild screams that respond to his deadpan claim "I shot a man in Reno, just to watch him die," are among the most thrilling moments in recorded sound.  But the whole thing would fall short as a gimmick if he only played jailhouse songs, & he doesn't, shrewdly filling out the set with folk ballads, parlor tunes, blues-based hits, new songs, & rarities that give an indicator of the range that he was capable of.  & like the best American music, it also barely scratched the surface.


9.  The King of the Delta Blues Singers, Robert Johnson. (1936-1937/1961)

Did Robert Johnson actually sell his soul to the Devil in exchange for his amazing blues musicianship?  We'll probably never know, but that doesn't matter — American myth has always proven greater than American truth, probably because it's always bigger.  For, when you listen to songs "Cross Road Blues," "Ramblin' on My Mind," "Stones in My Passway," & "Hell Hound on My Trail," it sure as hell sounds like a deal has been made with Satan (& bragged about in "Me & the Devil Blues").  This was music on a dark road that never ended, where any hope was sacrificed by pain, terror, & regret.  Is it any wonder that everyone ever since (including Bob Dylan, the Rolling Stones, & Eric Clapton, among scores more) couldn't get enough of it?


10.  Born to Run, Bruce Springsteen. (1975)

After the hard times of Vietnam & Watergate, America was having trouble gaining its footing — & its music was too.  Enter an eager scruffy kid from Jersey hailed as rock & roll's Next Big Thing, taking his place in line after Elvis & Dylan.  The thing is, as much as he tried to sound quintessentially American, he did sound quintessentially American, in a way that further expanded the sound as it celebrated it.  Songs like the title track & "Thunder Road" had dense instrumentation, winding lyrics, & a point of view fixed solely on the highway's horizon.  Although he famously sung of "a runaway American Dream," on Born to Run Springsteen caught the dream, & got out of it a majestic, restless, & loving album.

Sunday, July 1, 2012

Endless Summaries: One Man's Quest For The Perfect Beach Boys Compilation.

OK, this should not be so difficult.

The Beach Boys have officially been around for 50 years, & yet, a decent one-disc compilation seems to elude their catalogue.  At least in my opinion.

There was the old vinyl Best Of The Beach Boys, Volumes 1 & 2 that have been out of print longer than I've been alive.  Just as well since, despite Greil Marcus's claim about the second volume, they both seem to skimp on length (as many LPs did back then) & add some needless junk amongst the hits (namely, the Beach Boys trying to beat the Kinks in the contest for the worst "Louie, Louie" cover on Vol. 1 & something called "Long Tall Texan" on Vol. 2).  Sometimes there's a reason things are outta print.  Or, as my friend Sarah would say, meh.

The compilation that broke the mold, then, was 1974's surprise blockbuster Endless Summer, which to many people, is THE Beach Boys collection, if not statement.  It was only the second Beach Boys' LP to hit #1 — the first was their obligatory mid-'60s live album (& no, Pet Sounds never came close as it stalled at #10, although it did make #2 in the UK, but I digress) — & introduced an entire generation to the group, the very same people who ushered in their "America's Greatest Band" phase by the time they were rocking out for the Reagan White House on the 4th of July, which is about as American as a show can get, I'd say.

For this reason, people get pretty misty-eyed about Endless Summer, but upon closer examination nearly 40 years after the fact, the album reveals itself to be the slapdash afterthought it truly was.  Basically, by 1974, the Beach Boys had left Capitol to start their own Brothers label (& unknowingly enter their bizarre "cult" years between hit-makers & oldies-circuiters), & Capitol was looking to make a cheap buck off the band.  As you read everywhere, Endless Summer was made with the help of Mike Love (which, depending on if yer Team Brian, means that it was soiled by the hand of satan, or if yer Team Mike, it was graced by the great unsung hero of American popular music), which means he chose to focus on the Beach Boys' vintage years (1962-1965) to the exclusion of anything later — i.e., Pet Sounds & the #1 "Good Vibrations" (although we will soon see the latter oversight rectified).

It was this emphasis that made it so irresistible to the kids, as the post-'60s purple haze of glass onions & jewels & binoculars hanging from the head of the mule had overtaken the (often great) music that had come just before it.  Enter Endless Summer, which, say what you will about the music (& I will), came in a shiny double-set with lovely artwork — evocative line drawings of the boys among the green trees & yellow sand of the beach, which were a perfect match for the mood of the music inside, while oddly also being a perfect mismatch for the time in which the music was made (despite the fact that all of the recordings were around a decade old & made in their classic preppy matching-striped shirt days, the band was drawn with the long hair & flowing beards that was contemporary to 1974) — & perfect title.  Endless Summer.  Yes.  If there's a more perfect comp title, I've yet to see it.  OK, maybe the Flaming Lips' Finally The Punk Rockers Are Taking Acid, but that's more of an intellectual perfection where as Endless Summer works completely on mood.  Which is what this album is all about.

For everything that is on the album, it's interesting to note what isn't.  Big hits — "When I Grow Up (To Be A Man)" (#9), "Dance, Dance, Dance" (#8), "Do You Wanna Dance?" (#12), & "Barbara Ann" (#2) — are all MIA, despite the fact that they were all released during the 1962-1965 time period.  Also, minor hits & classics like "409" (#76), "Please Let Me Wonder" (#52), "The Little Girl I Once Knew" (#20), & "Little Honda" (the lead song on an EP that hit #44) are also missing.  & then, most sacrilege of all, on three tracks the less-familiar & inferior LP versions were substituted for the famous hit versions: "Be True to Your School" (#6), "Fun, Fun, Fun" (#5), & "Help Me, Rhonda" (one of the Beach Boys' few #1 hits).  This has always struck me as very fishy.  & with everyone agreeing on how thrown-together this compilation was, it's always just felt like some engineer somewhere wasn't really paying attention when they sent the masters to be pressed, & then it wasn't worth fixing once they had been sent, if anyone even noticed in the first place.  & then when it becomes a #1 smash, why fix something that's not broken?

So that's already five Top 40 hits from the period that was left off, plus an additional three Top 10 hits that weren't included in their hit versions.  Really, who was in charge here?  But what did make it on, wrong versions & all, play majestically.  In this regard, Endless Summer plays the ultimate trick of them all: Feeling like the perfect summation of the Beach Boys, even if reality proved otherwise.  For everything that the album wasn't, it was assembled shrewdly.  It balances between rockers & ballads, with the opening side of "Surfin' Safari" (#14) "Surfer Girl" (#7), "Catch A Wave," "The Warmth Of The Sun," & "Surfin' USA" (#3) especially perfect.  The big hits — "Little Deuce Coupe" (#15) "I Get Around" (#1) "California Girls" (#3) — are pretty evenly divided among the smaller ones — "In My Room" (#23), "Shut Down"(#23), & "Don't Worry Baby" (#24) — & the non-charting classics (at least in the relative world of the Beach Boys) like "Wendy," "You're So Good To Me," & "All Summer Long."  The few other filler tracks — "The Girls On The Beach," "Girl Don't Tell Me" & "Let Him Run Wild" — can be excused as filler, given the fact that you are getting a 20-song, double album.

But wait just a minute there — only one song breaks the three-minute barrier (the inferior version of "Rhonda"), while two don't even break the two-minute barrier, resulting in a breezy album that runs a little over 45 minutes.  That's shorter than the Beatles' Abbey Road, Bob Dylan's Highway 61 Revisited, & the Rolling Stones' original UK version of Aftermath, all of which sit comfortably on a single disc.  Indeed, while the average LP side can hold around 20-23 minutes, Endless Summer opts for around 12 on each of its side.  Thus, it could've been issued on a single LP — which, incidentally, is exactly how it was issued in the always-thrifty UK.  But Americans are all about space & a double-album feels fuller than a single, & this is an album all about feel.  Also, as any business undergrad can tell you, a double-album can be sold at a higher price.

& then I almost forgot.  When it was reissued on CD in 1981 (a double-album set on a single CD, ha ha!), they added what may have been the first bonus track ever: "Good Vibrations," a #1 single that even the most armchairy of armchair Beach Boy quarterbacks must've noticed was absent.  When you think Beach Boys (not to mention the phrase "Endless Summer"), I bet "Good Vibrations" is the first thing most people would think of.  Yes, it broke Mike Love's "early years" rule (it came out in 1966), but from the Reagan era, it all looked the same.  Beach/surf/hippie music.  Maybe it wasn't all so bad after all...

But with no other songs in between the original running-order & "Good Vibrations," the now 21-track, 51-minute CD Endless Summer, the album simply bypassed the Pet Sounds material altogether.  Perhaps this was allowed Mike Love to go with it, if he was even consulted when the transfer to CD was made.  Love had famously referred to Brian Wilson's Pet Sounds-era stuff as "Brian's Ego music," so in this version of the story, the ego music could still be out while the closer of all closers, "Good Vibrations," ends things with a gorgeousness that can't be denied by either Team Mike or Team Brian.  Or anyone with ears for that matter.

With the CD Endless Summer now neatly skipping Pet Sounds, it remained the optimal recommendation for many critics, just as the two albums appear in Rolling Stone's 200 Essential Albums list in 1997.  Unlike so many other artists, these albums seemed to fit together perfectly, with Endless Summer leading just up to Pet Sounds, Pet Sounds filling its own void, then the bonus track of "Good Vibrations" (released after Pet Sounds) to finish the story with seemingly everything you need to know.

But there are still the missing hits, & still the three inferior non-hit versions.  Now, I've read that when they put out the special remastered gold CD edition (Remember those things? Pay twice as much for an album that you've already bought on vinyl, cassette tape, and normal CD!), they corrected the inferior versions, making it the first time that you could actually hear all of the hits in the hit versions that the album's sleeve always claimed to have.  At any rate, my copy of the non-gold CD (an old Columbia House mail-order one I found used in a record store) has the stupid versions of the three songs.  (I mean, there's a reason why the single of "Help Me, Rhonda" doesn't playfully fade in & out for a few extra choruses.)

Now, assuming we can call the three "wrong tracks" issued resolved given that they were (finally) corrected, I still don't understand how some of those songs made it on the album.  Maybe I'm quibbling here (OK, I'm definitely quibbling here), but I can't believe that legitimate top ten hits like "Dance, Dance, Dance," "When I Grow Up (To Be A Man)," & "Barbara Ann" were MIA while second-rate, derivative fodder like "Girls On The Beach," "Girl Don't Tell Me," & "You're So Good To Me" made the cut.

It is probably for these very reasons (plus I don't think the sound was ever remastered for the non-gold CD edition) that Endless Summer has remained out of print for at least a decade now.  But what kills me most is that nothing good was put in its place.

The two-record 1986 set Made In The U.S.A. came the closest for me, chronologically taking the story up through Pet Sounds (adding "Caroline No," a minor hit (#34) that was issued as a "Brian Wilson" single) & "Good Vibrations," & then closing it with the one-two punch of "Heroes & Villains" (#12) & their made-in-1968-but-already-was-feeling-nostalgic "Do It Again" (#20), before then adding five needless newer oldies covers tacked on at the end.  Plus, when I look at it now, I see that, despite my very clear memories of the album, it apparently doesn't have "Little Deuce Coupe" on it.  Although I coulda sworn that my copy did.  At any rate, another Beach Boys aficionado could just as easily point to the absence of "In My Room" or "Catch A Wave" & make just as strong as an argument.  (For those keeping score, all three of those songs are on Endless Summer.)

The early 1990s saw a major remastering & reissuing of the Beach Boys catalogue for their 30th anniversary as a band, culminating in a boxed set, Good Vibrations: 30 Years of the Beach Boys, which is in its own category (& has already been masterly/obsessively deconstructed by David Leaf in his short revival of Crawdaddy! from that time).  By this point, they had been discovered by a third generation of fans, as highlighted by a surprise #1 single, "Kokomo," which I always hated, from the Cocktail soundtrack (Tom Cruise used to be famous for being an actor!), & seemingly omnipresent guest spots on Full House (in truth they only appeared a few times, usually with just one or two of the members).

Hot off the hit (in the box set world, anyway) box set, it was time to make a new, definitive CD of the Beach Boys hits, especially since they now had their fourth #1 hit!  But instead, they made The Greatest Hits — Volume 1: 20 Good Vibrations.  Issued in 1995, the album was the exact opposite of Endless Summer: With a corporate title & an ugly cover, it looked like the perfect summation of the Beach Boys' career, but had none of the feel.  At only 20 songs, it still only ran for about 50 minutes, meaning that another half hour of hits could've been added.  & also — clearly some misty-eyed Endless Summer-ers were at the helm here — they substituted the stupid versions of "School" & "Rhonda" for the hit versions.  Now they had no excuse.

Which is probably why only four years later, they weirdly reissued the album with the same name & title, but with a different (now chronological) running order & the actual hit versions of "School" & "Rhonda."  But still at only 20 tracks, it feels a bit skimpy, not to mention MIAs like "Don't Worry Baby" & "When I Grow Up (To Be A Man)" (does everybody really hate that song THAT much?), plus the awkward fact that there's a good 22 year gap between the 19th & the 20th songs ("Good Vibrations" & "Kokomo," respectively, natch).  The Greatest Hits — Volume 2: 20 More Good Vibrations filled in the cracks, but it definitely felt like leftovers, with the sputtering ballad start of "In My Room," "The Warmth Of The Sun," & "Don't Worry Baby," all excellent songs, but not the best way to start an album.  By the time they put out the third volume, of their cultish "Brothers" years, I'm not sure if anyone was paying attention anymore.  Except me, apparently.

Then two years The Beatles single-handedly changed the entire reissue playing field with 1, collecting 27 number one songs (well, 26 #1 songs technically, plus "Something," but I digress) between the US & UK charts on a single disc.  Not to be outdone, the Elvis people put out the weirdly titled ELV1S, which had 31 of his US, UK, & Cash Box #1s (well, I could quibble, but I'll refrain).  Before long, everybody from James Brown to Marvin Gaye to Elton John to the Bee Gees had to release THEIR albums of number one songs (although many would be quite liberal in their definition), with further acts like Three Dog Night, The Steve Miller Band, & Joe Cocker putting out as-many-songs-as-can-fit-on-a-disc compilations nobody asked for that tried to make up in breadth what it could make up for in chart positions.

It was only a matter of time before The Beach Boys jumped in the fray.  & so, in 2003 (to mark their 41st anniversary?), The Beach Boys released Sounds of Summer: The Very Best Of The Beach Boys, a single-disc, 30-track CD that sought to be the end-all, be-all Beach Boys compilation.

Only it wasn't.

To begin with, the songs were not in chronological order, something that I personally feel is essential for a grand retrospective (see: 1, ELV1S, etc.).  Instead, they were done as a sort of stream-of-consciousness flow that some praised but I thought failed miserably.  Hearing "Surfin' Safari" & "Surfin' USA" back-to-back does nothing to make either one better, while the "Surfer Girl" & "Don't Worry Baby" back-to-back is like, OK, it's now ballad time.  Also, this being a career-long sweep in the model of the other definitive single-disc compilations, they included their '70s & '80s hits that are at once less familiar & not as good, both in terms of songwriting strength & production values.  When "Wouldn't It Be Nice" gives way to "Getcha Back," it sounds as though someone has ripped off the record & replaced it with a #26 hit from 1985.  Which is exactly what it is.  (Here's an example of where chronology could solve the problem.)

Don't get me wrong, the Beach Boys did have some surprisingly respectable hits since "Do It Again," with 1969's "I Can Hear Music" (#24), 1976's "Rock and Roll Music" (#5, not sure how, but it was), & the aforementioned "Kokomo"; not to mention the minor hits between "Heroes & Villains" & "Do It Again" — namely, 1968's "Wild Honey" (#31) & "Darlin'" (#19).  But basically, anything more than these songs feels a bit over-inflated, which is exactly how tracks like 1978's "Come Go With Me" (#18) & 1979's "Good Timin'" (#40) are left in the mix, while other songs — most disgracefully, for me anyway, "409" & "Catch A Wave" — are left for the obligatory "leftovers" album Warmth Of The Sun (interesting for its own purposes, but will always feel like a weird detour as opposed to another complete version).

My guess is that the whole "no chronology" thing was done for Sounds Of Summer for one reason only: So that it could end with "Good Vibrations," just like how Endless Summer did (the way everyone remembers it, anyway).  But alas, the programming is too obvious, too thematic to work.

& so we are back where we started: Endless Summer.  Again I will take it out & again I will listen to it, but again I will hear just as much of what it could've been as I will what it is.

Seriously, it just shouldn't be this hard!

* * *

For all of you out there like me (& I know there are thousands of you!), I made up my own little "extended" Endless Summer, which I feel like captures the spirit (& tracklist) of the original, while then adding 10 extra bonus cuts that take the story up to "Do It Again," which (influence of Made In The USA admitted) seemed to take the story as far as it needed to go & in a way ended it the way it began.

I left the original running order alone, but substituted the hit versions for the stupid versions.  I then tacked on my extra 10 tracks, putting them chronologically (I wasn't gonna try mimicking the initial album's running order), but they still have a good flow.  & all tracks are in their mono mixes, as they should always be for everything ever.  (The mono/stereo can of worms is one I've deliberately avoided thus far & I intended to continue doing — or not doing — so.)

So here it is, yer 32-track compilation of The Beach Boys that they should make but somehow have not (& likely never will).  It's got the hit versions, it's got the golden years, it's got all of Endless Summer (even the filler cuts) & every Top 10 hit of the '60s.

I made me one & now you can too!

I call it—

Endless Summer [Reconstructed] [Bonus Tracks]

1.  Surfin' USA
2.  Surfer Girl
3.  Catch A Wave
4.  The Warmth Of The Sun
5.  Surfin' USA
6.  Be True To Your School (Single Version)
7.  Little Deuce Coupe
8.  In My Room
9.  Shut Down
10.  Fun, Fun, Fun (Single Version)
11.  I Get Around
12.  Girls On The Beach
13.  Wendy
14.  Let Him Run Wild
15.  Don't Worry Baby
16.  California Girls
17.  Girl Don't Tell Me
18.  Help Me, Rhonda (Single Version)
19.  You're So Good To Me
20.  All Summer Long
21.  Good Vibrations

[Bonus Tracks]

22.  409
23.  When I Grow Up (To Be A Man)
24.  Little Honda
25.  Dance, Dance, Dance
26.  Please Let Me Wonder
27.  Barbara Ann
28.  Sloop John B
29.  Wouldn't It Be Nice
30.  God Only Knows
31.  Heroes & Villains
32.  Do It Again

Oh, & if anyone at Capitol is reading this, feel free to give me a heads up.  I can't believe that a 50th anniversary is gonna go by with no new comp on deck...

Monday, May 14, 2012

“Paul's Boutique” & American Freedom (With Love to Adam “MCA” Yauch)

The Beastie Boys are the only band I ever got into to impress a girl.

One of this girl’s life goals was to marry Mike D, and so naturally I wanted to see what this Mike D had that I didn’t.  I bought Paul’s Boutique and drove East, listening to it over and over, until it went from obnoxious & whiny to hard & rocking.  The punchline is that by the time I made it East, I was pretty obsessed with them, and, in trying to impress her of my knowledge (i.e., chatting about the songs from their supposed abandoned country album), I accidentally showed her up, so that she was like, “Wow, you definitely know a lot more about them than I do.”  Cue awkward silence.  My OCD had foiled another plan, but at least I got the Beastie Boys out of it.

In part because it was the first Beastie Boys album I got into and in part because it the stone-cold classic of their catalogue, Paul’s Boutique is the album I always go back to, in a way I do few other albums in my life (my off-the-top-of-my-head shortlist of others would include Randy Newman’s Good Old Boys, the Zombies’ Odessey and Oracle, and Belle & Sebastian’s If You’re Feeling Sinister, but I digress).  As such, it was the album I went back to after Adam “MCA” Yauch passed away the other week.

It sucks how it takes someone’s death to re-appreciate their life, but for some reason it never fails to do the trick.  Paul’s Boutique had rarely sounded so rich, full, and funky; it was a 54-minute refresher on why this is my favorite rap album.

But to my ears, it plays as more than just a rap album, but an exercise in American freedom that is rarely matched by any other rock and roll, let alone by any other American music.  In its own way, I hear it falling into line not just with Elvis’s early pre-Army recordings and Bob Dylan’s pre-crash electric recordings, but Louis Armstrong’s Hot Fives & Sevens recordings, and Billie Holiday’s early Columbia recordings.  For, in very different ways, all of these records seem to tackle the same issue: Working out freedom through sound.

I once read this interview with Bono where he was making a sweeping statement that took in the history of rock and roll (so unlike him!).  He said something along the lines of: It used to be that if you wanted to be a legitimate rock and roll band, you had to get your instruments together and practice a whole bunch, but then punk came along in the mid-’70s as a great equalizer such that anyone could pick up instruments and be a legitimate band later that day.  And now, Bono continued, with DJs and turntables, you don’t even need to make your own record!  You can just play part of someone else’s record and use that as your rock band.  The great equalizer, Bono seemed to be saying, had gotten equalized itself.  Or as Chuck D put it: “Run-D.M.C. first said a DJ could be a band/Stand on your own feet/Get you outta your seat!”

Indeed, Run-D.M.C. was the first major rap group and pioneered the music with a hard, stripped-down beat and sparse, if any, instrumentation.  When the Beastie Boys began making rap music, they modeled themselves on Run-D.M.C., eventually touring with them, and, on “Slow and Low,” picking up the group’s leftovers for their own debut album.  That album was Licensed to Ill, and with “Fight for Your Right (to Party)” powering it, it became the first number one rap album ever.  Licensed to Ill was produced by the Beasties’ old college friend Rick Rubin in 1986, the same year that he ushered Run-D.M.C. towards their first mainstream (read: white) success: A hip-hop cover of Aerosmith’s “Walk This Way,” which is now rightly seen as a turning point in the history of modern popular music.

The Beasties could’ve stayed with Rubin and kept remaking Licensed to Ill until their sales dwindled and they had to wait around for a retro-old school craze to sweep them back up again, but they chose not to.  Instead, they parted ways with Rubin, moved to LA, and hooked up with the Dust Brothers.

Unlike Rick Rubin’s sparse production values, the Dust Brothers pioneered a dense sound in rap music that layered countless samples (often on top of each other) that was, in its own way, as full and exciting as Phil Spector’s Wall of Sound.  It was a Wall of Samples.

Using this sound as a base, the Beastie Boys rose to the challenge by becoming exponentially better MCs than they had been on their first album; as a quantum leap in talent and identity from a debut to a sophomore album, the Beasties are perhaps only topped by Bob Dylan.  They take the ever-changing kaleidoscope of samples and keep pace with a never-ending spew of fast and surreal rhymes that name-checks just as much as the music sample-checks.  Its speed and variety set the stage for such latter-day television shows as Mystery Science Theater 3000, 30 Rock, and Community — not to mention anything that Aaron Sorkin ever penned — while as American culture, its clearest parallel is Melville’s The Confidence-Man, in which the title character takes on a new form with each chapter in an ultimate gesture of reinvention.  But the Beasties even beat Melville at his own game: They shift form with almost every new line.

Much has been made of the breadth with which Paul’s Boutique takes a swath of culture, eating it up and spewing it back out in its own image, but listening to it again, I’m struck by how much of it junk culture, the kind of things you come across while flipping channels while putting off your afterschool homework.

In the album, one can find allusions to The Patty Duke Show, The Brady Bunch, and The Flintstones, and that’s just the first song.  Listen to the second, about a washed-up rockabilly star-turned-wino, and you can add to that list the Beatles’ “Helter-Skelter,” Bob Dylan’s “Maggie’s Farm,” Jean Knight’s “Mr. Big Stuff,” Carl Perkins’ “Blue Suede Shoes,” and Elvis shaving his head to join the Army.  In the third, about driving around and egging LA, you can find Mother Goose’s Humpty-Dumpty, Looney Tunes’ Yosemite Sam, and Dr. Suess’s Green Eggs & Ham, over samples that cop Curtis Mayfield’s “Superfly,” the score from Hitchcock’s Psycho, and the lyrics of the Beatles’ “I Am the Walrus.”  And that doesn’t even mention the scores of allusions to and clichés about eggs.  Just when you think you’ve heard them all, they throw another one at you.  It’s actually rather astounding.

You get the picture.  And it doesn't let up.  Everyone from Vincent Van Gogh to Charles Dickens to Harry S Truman to Raymond Burr to J.D. Salinger to Colonel Saunders to Alfred E. Neumann makes a cameo, over music that samples James Brown’s “Funky Drummer,” Sister Sledge’s “We Are Family,” Chic’s “Good Times,” and the Commodores’ “Machine Gun” (not to mention other things from the Deliverance soundtrack on down to a ping-pong ball), and direct splices from lines in Johnny Cash’s “Folsom Prison Blues,” the Ramones’ “Suzie Is a Headbanger,” the Funky 4+1’s “That’s the Joint,” Sweet’s “Ballroom Blitz,” Bob Marley’s “Stop That Train,” Public Enemy’s “Bring the Noise,” and more.

But for me, the most astounding thing is “Sounds of Science,” a song whose very title suggests culture allusion, this time to Simon & Garfunkel’s “The Sounds of Silence,” best experienced in the extended opening of Mike Nichols’ The Graduate.  Beginning with the supper-club two-step of the Beatles’ (THE BEATLES!) “When I’m Sixty-Four,” the Beasties turn their attention from throwing eggs and speeding cars to, well, science.  Everyone from Galileo to Newton to Franklin to Einstein is name-checked, as the Beasties appropriately rap about “expanding the rhymes of sucka MC amateurs.”  But then, about halfway through, the song breaks off into an old-school style breakdown over the fanfare that begins Sgt. Pepper, before restarting the song full speed ahead on top beats lifted from Ringo’s drum solo in “The End.”  With the Sgt. Pepper fanfare still continuing in a loop underneath, the song samples fucking Abbey Road over Sgt. Pepper!  And what music are the Beasties actually referring to in their rhymes at this point in the song?  Um, the Grease soundtrack.

Because of moments like this, Paul’s Boutique could never be made now or ever again.  By slipping in the tail beginning of rap’s first era of sampling bonanza, it broke the mold.  As per usual, the law showed up after the fact to try and put the genie back in the bottle: Any more than 5 seconds of sound was liable to copyright infringement, blah, blah, blah.  But by being one of the first, Paul’s Boutique was able to get by unscathed, the one they let get away as they waved their fist and swore would never happen again.  (Actually, the only other album that truly meets it is De La Soul’s 3 Feet High and Rising, but to me, Paul’s Boutique has always played as the stronger, tighter record…although I’ll admit that, as a northern white kid of Jewish descent listening to other northern white kids of Jewish descent, it may have been more on my level, but I digress.)

In this way, Paul’s Boutique expands more than just the rhymes of MC amateurs, but the boundaries of freedom in postwar American culture.  The album is a patchwork quilt of other people’s work, ripped up and reassembled as something new, and ultimately worthy in its own right.

We are a nation of borrowers, of lenders, of thieves, and of tricksters; we are, as Melville knew all along, a nation of Confidence-Men, ever shifting, ever changing, unwilling and unable to be pinned down until there is nothing left but freedom – and, if you’re lucky, the name you were born with.

Or as the late, great MCA says towards the end of “The Sounds of Science”: “No one really knows what I’m talking about/Yeah, that’s right, my name’s Yauch.”

Thursday, April 19, 2012

Last Thoughts on Levon Helm, 1940-2012.

Over the years, Levon Helm was many things and he cropped up in many places: He was a rock and roll legend with a revitalized career who hosted group jams that anyone could sit in on; he was the abusive coal mining father to Sissy Spacek’s Oscar-winning portrayal of Loretta Lynn in Coal Miner’s Daughter; he was the down-home southern narrator to the wonderful (and now-forgotten) documentary Elvis ’56; and, of course, he was the drummer and often lead vocalist for the Band.

I found out about the Band the same way that most people in my generation did: From my parents’ vinyl collection. Their self-titled “Brown Album” was the one my parents had, and as a result, “The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down” was the first song of theirs I remember hearing. Which means that, like so many others, my first encounter with the Band was with Levon’s voice. And I don’t think I would’ve wanted it any other way.

“The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down” was Levon’s song, but as is usually the case with the Band, nothing is quite that simple. A true collaborative group, their best music, found on their first two albums, was written as a team, less like a baseball or football team than a team of great storytellers swapping tales like gamblers in the back of the saloon, trying to outdo each other while still contributing something essential to the whole. There was a lot going on, but none of it ever felt forced or unnecessary. And as the drummer, Levon is the one who anchored it all.

Greil Marcus once famously described the Band as four Canadians held together by an Arkansas drummer, and that hit the nail on the head. The Band had always been Levon's band – he was its senior member and the one who kept it going between their celebrated stints with Ronnie Hawkins and Bob Dylan as Levon and the Hawks – and he was the only one in this archetypal Americana band who was actually American.

And appropriately, it was in the heart of the South, with Levon, that the Band’s story began. Recruited by local B-level rockabilly singer Ronnie Hawkins as a drummer for his backing band the Hawks, Levon went to Canada with them in the early ’60s, where there was still an audience for authentic rough-and-tumble American rockabilly. Over the months, as Levon’s fellow Hawks quit, gave up, or went back home, they were replaced, one-by-one, by local Canadian boys. Before long, Levon found himself to be the sole yankee, surrounded by guitarist Robbie Robertson, bassist Rick Danko, pianist Richard Manuel, and organist Garth Hudson. Eventually Levon even outlasted Hawkins himself, taking the group back to the states where they played an endless string of clubs, pubs, and dives.

It was at one of these places, the Peppermint Club in New York City, where they first hooked up with Bob Dylan. At the time, Dylan was looking for a band to lead for his first electric tour and the Band was looking to have a set professional gig. It was a match in proverbial rock and roll heaven. That was loud. Very, very loud.

But the ensuing tour proved to be one of the most controversial events of rock and roll history, as audiences often jeered and rejected this new electric incarnation of Dylan. Lines were drawn between the audience and the performers, and the concerts often played out like a war in sound and fury. Levon, for one, grew disenchanted – he said he didn’t play music to get booed – and sat out for most of the tour (including the legendary “Royal Albert Hall” concert where someone shouted “Judas!” to Dylan), literally jumping ship to work on an army boat for a string of months before reconnecting with the group on the other side in the summer and fall of 1967, where they were recording the loose, weird music now known as Dylan and the Band’s “Basement Tapes.”

Everyone took turns playing drums in Levon’s absence, with Manuel doing it the most regularly. Levon always maintained that Manuel was the better drummer anyway, and when he rejoined, he initially only contributed mandolin. But as their basement recordings found their way out onto bootleg records and demo tapes for other artists, the Band’s reputation grew in stature, and they were able to land a lucrative deal with Capitol Records, releasing their first two albums, Music from the Big Pink and the self-titled “Brown Album,” in 1968 and 1969.

They were among the finest and most influential records in rock and roll history. In retrospect, the Band mark the point at which the passing whims of current rock fads – “British invasion rock,” “folk rock,” “psychedelic rock,” and the rest – give way to what we now think of as “classic rock,” a rootsy, back-to-basics organic sound that the Band pioneered. Music from the Big Pink was released on July 1, 1968; by December, the Rolling Stones had officially abandoned their psychedelic misadventure with the back-to-basics Beggars Banquet, which featured gritty hits like “Street Fighting Man” and “Sympathy for the Devil,” while the Beatles planned their grand back-to-basics project, which became the Let It Be album and film, early the following year. George Harrison sang the Band’s praises and envied their teamwork, while Eric Clapton left Cream upon hearing the Band, secretly wishing they would ask him to join them when he first met them.

By abandoning pretentions and consciously shunning any modern passing fancies, the Band paradoxically found themselves at the center of all that was hip and innovative in rock and roll. Not that they had the chart hits to go along with it. Music from the Big Pink only hit #30 on the album charts while its accompanying single, “The Weight,” only made #63, perhaps putting them behind only the Velvet Underground for the decade’s most influential music that translated to the least amount of popular sales. But when they got ready to release their next album, it was seen as enough of an event that they were featured on the cover of Time Magazine.

And to my ears, that sophomore album, The Band, is their masterpiece. It plays like a rock and roll version of the Great American Novel, an utterly timeless, seemingly all-encompassing signature achievement.

The album has pop and rock, blues and country, high-mountain yodeling and middle-of-the-ocean sea-shanties, and down-home rag music, like “Rag Mama Rag,” which Levon doesn’t so much sing as he does unleash a nineteenth-century equivalent of a wall of sound, voices shouting, violins searing, pianos banging, drums collapsing upon themselves, and a tuba churning underneath it all, as one pictures whatever the wagon train pioneers did at night in the place of a rave.

The album has guitars and fiddles, pianos and organs, drums and horns, and what sounds like a giant radioactive Jew harp (actually Hudson’s organ run through a wah-wah pedal), which churns under “Up on Cripple Creek,” at #25 the biggest hit the Band would ever have, sung with gleeful abandon by Levon, as he adds his natural charm to a tall-tale of love caught on the sly, until it becomes the Band’s funkiest – and sexiest – song. It also is the rare song that both alludes to other music (seven perfect words: “We had Spike Jones on the box”) and is alluded to in other music (The Beastie Boys’ lifting “I bet on one horse to win, and another to show” for their Paul’s Boutique), which of course only strengthens the chain on either side, as well as within itself.

The album has songs about old men and part-time lovers, unfaithful servants and union members, women hiding guns and men who are thieves (and dig it), wild storm warnings and lonesome pines, and transcending it all is Virgil Caine, a Confederate Army veteran who loves the land he was born on and has seen it at its best and at its worst, and sings short lines that encompass long passages of time, until he becomes noble, or like a ghost with nothing left to do but tell his story to himself, which is to say, to anyone listening, to us.

It is Levon’s – and arguably the Band’s – finest performance. Robertson had written “The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down” for Levon, tapping into Levon’s knowledge about the sights, sounds, and feelings of the Civil War and spinning them into lyrics that resonate like few other depictions of the event. “In the winter of ’65,” Levon sings at one point, not so much destitute as he is merely reciting facts that have long since dulled his saga until they feel blank, “We were hungry, just barely alive.”

As he sung it, I wonder if Levon didn’t think back to the winter of 1965, when he had freshly left Dylan and the Band to strike out on his own on the army boat, and how lonesome he may have felt without his musical comrades around him; he certainly found his way back all right. I also wonder how many other people listening to the song in 1969 assumed it was referring the winter of 1965, and thought back to their own recent past, which, only four years later, must have seemed quite distant in its own right.

But make no mistake, “The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down” is about 1865, and the fall of the South in the Civil War, and America, and so much more. It’s said that our modern-day interpretation of the Civil War as a “brother against brother” conflict is a fairytale we tell ourselves because it was actually a failed second revolution to free the slaves, which imploded in the Reconstruction era, a time that we’d much rather skip over altogether than even bother to make up a fairytale about. African American slaves got their freedom, but at what cost? The sharecropping system and our country’s sense of integrity. Is it any wonder we’d rather think about a strapping white guy with a mustache dressed in blue shaking hands with a strapping white guy with a mustache dressed in gray?

As a cultural artifact, “The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down” is near bottomless. It demonstrates the “brother against brother” myth by taking the perspective of a southerner to elicit northern sympathy (as was done in countless Civil War artifacts, from – yikes! – Birth of a Nation on down through The General and Gone With the Wind), for, by tapping into that quiet sense of forlornness, it allows the northerner to put themselves into the southerner’s boots and understand their pain, if only for a moment, because as their once and future countryman, only they can truly know it. Just as we can only hate someone that we once loved, so too can we only love someone that we once hated.

In this way, every gesture in the song, no matter how small, becomes enormous. A yankee lays Virgil’s brother in his grave; Virgil’s wife calls for him to come quick and watch Robert E. Lee go by; Virgil is reduced to hunger and chopping wood with worthless confederate bills in his pocket. Each moment in the song is entirely imagined and yet entirely real, an idea about a time trapped in a time, a color picture of a black-and-white photograph.

And holding it all together from both ends is, of course, Levon: His vocals are what imbue the song with such richness, his drumming is what turns it from a march to a funeral to a wistful sing-a-long in a matter of seconds. Levon always liked hunting through old instrument shops when working on an album, and just before recording The Band, he stumbled upon an old wooden drumset that he purchased and used on the record. I suppose they were used on the entire album, but I feel like I can most clearly hear them on “The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down.” It makes sense that these wooden drums that hold the beat because the music sounds so rustic, so sturdy, like it was made out of old hickory like Andy Jackson.

And with his smooth drawl and his mischievous grin, Levon Helm was the perfect person to sit behind them and tell the tale that he never lived but somehow always knew.

Sunday, April 15, 2012

The Titanic at 100.

At this exact moment – 11:40 PM, April 14 – exactly 100 years ago, the Titanic struck the iceberg…and the modern world began.

I commemorated this event, as I had been planning to do all year, by watching A Night to Remember – a “real” Titanic movie, as I told my wife, as opposed to the dreck that James Cameron’s great-grandchildren can live off of until the Titanic’s 300th anniversary. We watched the movie (my apologies, I mean film) and were both moved and amazed, but as we talked about the events it portrayed, we kept going back to the Cameron film. Love it or hate it, like the Titanic itself, it had become an impenetrable fact.

Ironically, A Night to Remember was originally made as a response to an over-the-top Hollywood smash called Titanic. This was the 1953 Clifton Webb film Titanic that everyone thinks they mean when they see A Night to Remember but are deeply mistaken. I remember watching the 1953 Titanic on TV with my grandmother back in the Reagan administration and watching all of the cleanly-scrubbed men go down on the ship singing “Nearer My God to Thee” in brave unison. It was on that day that I learned the concept of “women and children first,” which was a foreign notion to my post-feminism upbringing, but I digress.

When A Night to Remember was made five years after the 1953 Titanic, its makers strove to make their film everything that the earlier film was not, which is to say, they strove for that elusive beast of “authenticity” over story. As much as possible, things were based on personal testimony, and any one lead character or storyline was sacrificed for a constantly shifting ensemble narrative that in some respects was closer to a documentary than a romantic epic. It is strange to think that the film was made only about 45 years after the initial tragedy, which is as far away from its day as the release of Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club was from the time that I write this. And I grew up on that album. That record was part of my parents – and in turn, our – lives.

This firsthand approach must be what gives A Night to Remember its excitement and energy; I literally spent the entire second half of the movie waiting “just two more minutes” before getting up to refill my water glass because the idea of pausing the film didn’t cross my mind as a possibility.

My wife pointed out the one major aspect of the film that is not accurate – the boat doesn’t split in two when it sinks, because nobody would realize that until Alvin the submarine (named after a chipmunk created for a novelty Christmas song the same year that A Night to Remember was released, but I digress) stumbled upon it in the mid-’80s, finally pinning its exact location down after some 70-odd years and correcting the story of how it sunk.

One feels like James Cameron must’ve began sketching out the storyboards to his 1997 Titanic the minute this discovery was made in an effort to make a perfect “unsinkable” film about the boat. He had the one thing that previous filmmakers did not: The hindsight of history.

I’ve only seen the Cameron Titanic once – I initially boycotted it as I do most films that present themselves as The Greatest Thing Ever (hence I still have yet to see a Lord of the Rings movie) – but I relented when they were showing it for free while I was in college. I must’ve had absolutely no homework left to do that night.

At any rate, I finally saw it and found it to be one of the funniest movies I’d seen in a long time (my favorite bit of dialogue being where Rose tells the ship’s architect she knows what was troubling him because she could see the iceberg in his eyes), down through to the drawn-out, ridiculous finale. I felt bad for the main character, I thought during it’s second half: The boat. What a beautiful boat, and amazing visual effects achievement, and now it’s wrecked and gone.

It wasn’t until recently that I figured out what it was about the Cameron Titanic that made it tick: It was a movie disguised as a film for teenage girls who thought that they were experiencing a film that was really a movie; in this regard, it was the cinematic equivalent of Margaret Mitchell’s Gone with the Wind – it seems like such “adult” stuff when approached in adolescence, but pretty quickly it reveals itself to be kinda dumb once one experiences the onset of adulthood.

That, and I couldn’t get past the fact that, if the movie was supposed to take place in 1997, the “old Rose” character would’ve had to have been around 120 years old. Maybe that’s a technical gripe, but all Cameron had to do was set the movie in the mid-’80s – and you could do that by setting the story around the ship’s rediscovery that revealed where it actually was – and get a much tighter, more realistic film. Oh wait, I mean movie.

But at the root of all of the things the Titanic story can tell us about nature, technology, and class, it remains the simplest story imaginable: Man builds machine, flies too close to the sun, and pays the hefty price. The fact it was also the first “modern” media event only cemented it in our collective unconscious, seeming much more immediate than, say, World War I, which was much bigger, costlier, and more important.

I used to have a professor who said that historical films tell you more about the time in which they were made than the time they try to depict, and somehow I feel like that’s relevant when thinking about the Titanic. Only, somehow, it feels as though it’s the Titanic that has stayed the same and we who have changed, challenging us to measure ourselves up against its burden.

It is this element that keeps the story fresh and fascinating, and bigger than ourselves, yet eerily intimate. In other words, it’s a story that reminds us what it means to be human.